Why targeting specific schools is not always a good idea

0 comments

Posted on 22nd December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

According to a survey from Alterian just 43% of larger firms segmentalise their email marketing lists.

With smaller companies the number is much lower – most companies tend to send out emails to everyone on their list.

Which leads me to wonder – is it worth segmentalizing when emailing schools?

On one basis one might say “no” since it costs much the same amount to send emails to 100 schools as it does to send them to 29,000 schools.

But there is also the issue of the message to consider.

For example if you have a pitch that is relevant to the new Free Schools, and you talk about Free Schools in the email, then it is going to look a bit silly if the email goes to a long established LA school.

However there is the issue “is it necessary to write specifically about free schools?” 

What we find is that many people write texts in which the mention of the group to whom the email is addressed is wholly gratuitous.  As in “As a newly formed Free School you will know.”  

Well, yes, but I think they already know they are a free school.  Why tell them?

The same applies to all groups of schools that get special money – such as all the schools working with children at the bottom end of the economic spectrum, that have large numbers of pupils getting free school meals.  

You might want to write to them because these schools have got some extra money.   But then the new Free Schools have extra money too.  So have schools that have recently changed headteachers.  So have some academies. 

And a lot of schools have saved a fair amount of money this school year and will be spending it by April 5.   You could email all of the schools.  All you have to do is to change the text.

In the end the problem comes down to the way in which the email is written.  If you say, “if you have got money left over or new money this year from the government” then you are not focussing the reader on the current situation.  You are just being boring talking about what the teacher already knows.  The recipients know the school’s financial position; you don’t have to tell them.

This approach of putting your offer into the context of the recipient’s current situation is called (naturally) contextualising, and by and large it doesn’t work – simply because it ends up with us writing about what the reader already knows.

And the problem with segmentalisation is that when we know we are writing to one segment of the database, most of us tend to contextualise.

Of course you need to segmentalise sometimes.  It is good to separate out your list of primary and secondary schools if you are selling books, because they need different books. 

But when emailing it is not always a good idea to make your list smaller and smaller – because you will then be drawn into talking to the recipient about everything that he already knows – and that will undoubtedly help to kill off the sale.

If you would like to go back over some of our earlier commentaries, they are on www.blog.educationmarketing.org.uk

Tony Attwood 

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

Asking teachers what they want

0 comments

Posted on 21st December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

Promoting your company to teachers always has one big problem, no matter how you do it.  You have to convince the teacher to have an interest in what you are saying

But supposing you could write to teachers who had already said that they were specifically, at that moment, interested in your product or service.

This is what we are going to try and achieve in 2012: getting teachers to come to our clients with requests for information.

First off, we are writing to teachers asking them if there are particular products or services they are lookin

Then we gather up the replies, and forward them to companies that we know are involved in the relevant area of work – and in effect putting teacher in touch with supplier.

The mechanism we are using for the link is the School Procurement Site – www.top5.org.uk   Only the companies listed on that site will have their details sent on to teachers who request information.  

In the trials we have done we’ve had varying success with the programme – and we’re not yet at the stage of being able to say that it will bring in x or y amount of sales.   So we are running the service with no charge to companies beyond the nominal £25 it costs to have a listing on www.top5.org.uk

If you want to be part of the programme, just go to the School Procurement Site link above, and then having seen what it is all about, go to http://www.top5.org.uk/Suppliers.html to see how to be listed.

The basic listing as noted above is £25 for a year, and this will include  the first rounds of our contacting teachers to ask what products or services they are specifically looking for, and forwarding on any relevant results.

But apart from being within that service you will of course be on the site for a year and so will benefit from teachers looking through the site for details of suppliers.   Do remember that although only a minority of teachers will send us an email saying “I am looking for x or y” many more will go onto www.top5.org.uk and search on their subject area – and our emails will be promoting this.

Hope you find this new idea interesting.  If you want to talk about it I am in the office 21/22 December – but after that, the office is closed for Xmas/New Year.

Tony

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

What surprised me this year

0 comments

Posted on 20th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

What did we learn this year about selling into schools in 2011?

In terms of selling into schools I think we not only learned quite a few things during the year, we were all fairly surprised by what happened.  Here’s a summary of the three big lessons I am taking away from this year, and will be using in my own marketing in 2012.

First, and most importantly, we saw the return of postal direct mail as a profitable way of selling to schools. 

With so many firms having pulled out of postal marketing, the approach now appears to many teachers to be unusual, with the result that a higher percentage of the advertising material now gets read by teachers than for many a long year. 

What’s more, postal promotions are now perceived as being more important, more significant and more likely to be about products and services of quality.  

This doesn’t mean email can’t work – we are still getting some terrific results from personal and subscription email.  But in sending out emails you do have to work particularly hard on the copy, to overcome the doubts that now seem to surround emails.  (If you want to see some do’s and don’t concerning email marketing, take a look at our regular blog, www.goodad.co.uk which contains reviews of lots of such adverts.)

So the first thing is that postal marketing is working again: I’d make that the big finding of the year.

The second big surprise was just how big was the bonus that regular advertisers accrued towards the end of 2011.   A lot of firms did cut back or even gave up on their advertising during the course of the year, feeling perhaps that the cut backs from government made it too difficult to sell anything.

But during the last six weeks we have had four separate companies write – not in response to questionnaires, but simply because they wanted to tell us what had happened.  Each said that they had just had the most extraordinary response to a promotion that they had seen in years.  One even cancelled a regular meeting with us because they were struggling to cope with the response!

The firms came from utterly different areas: one promoting theatre in education, one offering a service collecting up old IT equipment for safe disposal, and two selling resources.   Two of the firms used email, two used the post. 

But all four had been advertising regularly, and knew exactly what they would normally get in the last couple of months of the year.   The evidence suggests that  they got it right through regular advertising, and good use of the medium they chose.

My final point in terms of what we have learned must relate to blogs.  The vast majority of companies selling into schools are not running a blog, or are posting to it rarely, or are just posting adverts.  But the few who are posting informative interesting pieces about their area of interest are getting readers and sales.  And (and this is the big point) this is just about the most cost effective form of advertising that there is.

If you want to see a blog other that the one mentioned above take a look at www.blog.educationmarketing.org.uk   If you want something to amuse you over Christmas when there’s nothing on TV and the family isn’t full of conversation, try www.blog.toppled.info

So taking these points, this is where I would start in 2012:

Do both postal and email marketing – with maybe some short run postal test mailings that usually pay for themselves.

  1. Keep running the adverts – especially next term when it looks as if many schools will be anxious to spend all their money before April 5
  2. Start working on a blog – it is the most cost effective approach to marketing there is.

I do hope you have found some of these thoughts during the year helpful, I hope you’ll have a lovely Christmas/New Year holiday, and I do hope you will continue to read my ramblings in 2012.

Very best wishes

Tony Attwood and everyone at Hamilton House Mailings

Do one thing this holiday

0 comments

Posted on 16th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

If you have any spare time this holiday season, and you want to spend it doing something that will benefit your business then, if you don’t already have one, start a blog.

If you don’t know how to do it, type “how to set up a blog” into Google.

If you have a blog but don’t write something on it each day – then use the holiday period to write some more blogs.

And finally, contemplate this challenge.  Drop me a line telling me what you sell, and I will come back to you, without any charge or obligation, with a set of details of articles you could put on your blog.

(If you would like us to set up a blog for you, we can do that.  Details are at http://www.hamilton-house.com/blogs 

If you are looking for someone to help you write the blog we can do that to as part of a Velocity programme – see www.velocity.ac)

Tony Attwood

Follow us on Twitter @HHMailings

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

Check who is not getting your email

0 comments

Posted on 15th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

Local authorities have a habit of blocking emails into schools.  Some do it vigorously, some do it haphazardly, but one way or another they all do it.

As a result, it is more than likely that in some parts of the country your emails might not be getting through.

To give an example of just how this happens, last year we undertook emailings to schools for a group of local authorities, sending out the LAs own newsletters.  All was fine until one of the authorities started blocking all the emails.  They were in fact blocking their own promotions!!!

It actually took us two weeks of hard slog to get the blockage removed, with someone who always signed themselves “Administrator” claiming that he/she had standing orders to block any email sender that sent bulk email.  That person got a severe reprimand for a senior exec of the authority in the end, but it was very frustrating for us in the meanwhile.

Tests we have done suggest that at any time most email senders will have some of their mail blocked by LAs unless they constantly monitor where emails are not getting through, and then work personally with the LA to prove that they are a reputable firm with the interest of the schools at heart.

For HHM this work is easier than for some firms since many of the emails we send out are to teachers who have requested our subscription newsletters (and they get very irate if the LA stops them receiving their twice weekly update), and because of credibility we gain in running the School of Education Administration (www.admin.org.uk)   

But we have seen situations in which 30 or more LAs are blocking a sender at any one time , and because they don’t check, they don’t know.

I’m thinking of this today because we have just managed to unblock one LA that has been causing us a problem for the past three weeks, and that is a relief for us.  But I know we’ll have someone else starting it again next term, and we’ll be on the case at once.

I would always suggest that you check your responses to see that they come from across the UK, and that you are not getting a situation in which some areas bring you in no orders at all.

No one can achieve 100% penetration of schools across the UK all the time, because of the way LAs operate their blocking systems, but you should be aiming for 98%, with work going on to unblock those that are causing you grief.

There are details of our email lists on www.emails.gs

You can stay in touch with our newsletters and read past items on www.blog.educationmarketing.org.uk and follow us on Twitter @HHMailings

And you can call us on 01536 399 000.

Tony

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

The great howler

0 comments

Posted on 12th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

My favourite email today.  From Jo Brown, the clothing catalogue.

“So Christmas is quite literally around the corner.”

Err… no it isn’t.  Christmas is a date, and dates don’t go round corners.  Christmas is metaphorically just around the corner.

What next?  It is literally raining cats and dogs?

Tony

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

A video on your web site? Beware

0 comments

Posted on 12th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

We recently did a survey of teachers who are subscribers to our Education Management News service (a free email service akin to this newsletter, but one that takes adverts).

In it we asked about the use of You Tube in schools.  We asked particularly, as of late we have had a number of clients who have put You Tube type videos on their home page in order to draw customers in.

What we found was that only half of the teachers who replied felt they could always view You Tube videos without hindrance at school.

About a quarter said that some You Tube links are blocked.  A quarter said ALL You Tube type links are blocked.

In a separate part of the survey 10% of teachers indicated that although they can see You Tube they can’t get sound on the computer that they use at work (mostly because it is in an area such as a staff room, with no headphones available.)

Given that such a significant proportion of teachers might not be able to see your video, it does suggest that making it a central part of your on line publicity might not always be the best move.

If you would like to know more about Education Management News and how to advertise within it please go to http://www.emails.gs/emailteachersdirect.html

Footnote: if you are interested in wider aspects of postal and email marketing you might also enjoy our regular email via the DMS news group.  To subscribe free of charge send an email to Direct-mail-secrets-subscribe@yahoogroups.com

Tony Attwood

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

Where do these numbers come from?

0 comments

Posted on 9th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

I wrote a little while ago about a company that seemed to be claiming to have the personal opt in email address of each and every teacher in the UK.

Apart from the problem of doing such research, and the minor detail that huge numbers of primary school teachers don’t have or use their own personal email address at school, there was the problem of “opt in”.   How could anyone convince virtually everyone on a database to “opt in”.

Now we’ve got another funny number coming up – although at least this time I’ve been able to resolve the issue.

According to the Department for Education there’s 1,463 Academies in England, and yet I have seen one company advertising closer to 1,500 schools of this type.

I naturally checked our database – and we have 1,463 exactly as the Department does.  So where did all the other ones come from.

The answer I suspect is via annexes.  Some schools, when they become Academies, merge a couple of schools together, and then make one of the original schools an Annexe of the new Academy.

Add the numbers together and there are 1,522 school addresses.

OK – it is a small difference, but worth knowing because if you were to mail the annexes without knowing, you would be wasting maybe £20 on mailings which you don’t want to do.  Not much, but still….

Anyway, you can buy the list for one year’s unlimited re-use for £195 plus VAT, including within it all the usual things – school name and address, headteacher’s name, generic email address, type of academy that it is, phone number.

We normally supply without the annexes listed, but if you want them included, just say so and we’ll pop them in for no extra cost.

You can have the list as an email attachment or on CD (that means an extra £4.95 courier fee).  Email us an order with your full details any time up to mid day on 22 December to have the list at this special price.

If you want to go follow us day by day we are on Twitter @HHMailings

Tony Attwood

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

Teachers can tell you what they want

0 comments

Posted on 8th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

Each week HHM sends emails to teachers in various departments relating to products and services that will be of relevance to them.  Quite often they write back and tell us about the sort of products or services they are looking for.

Some of these requests can be met by a number of firms, and we refer the teacher to our School Procurement Web Site www.top5.org.uk  

Some are rather more obscure – like the request that I reprint below, and so I either mention them here, or send them on to the firms listed in the web site quoted above.

But additionally we do overtly go out to teachers and ask them on a subject by subject basis to tell us what particular topics, products or services they need help on.  Again we forward details of these replies to companies listed on www.top5.org.uk

I’ll be announcing the schedule of which teachers we will be writing to next term, in a short while, but to make sure you receive copies of enquiries in your subject, it is worth making sure you are listed on the site.  If you are not, you can be.  The fee is just £25 plus VAT per year, and if you are interested, just email Chris@hamilton-house.com or call 01536 399 000.

You can do more than have the standard format (such as including a logo) – for an extra charge.  There are details on http://www.top5.org.uk/Suppliers.html

In the meanwhile, here’s the very specific request from a teacher in Wales.  If you have anything for her, just email me the details and I will forward them.

As a Special Needs teacher in a special school, teaching KS3/4 pupils at levels P6-NC level 1 I find the whole system ignores our needs and the needs of the pupils we serve.

I work in Wales which means we have the added joy of working from the Welsh Assembly Government documents and in many cases having to use English curriculum resources, assessment processes which don’t match our learning objectives and outcome statements/level descriptors, as an added layer of annoyance when already adapting the curriculum for our learners. It would be a joy to be able to buy or download Schemes of Work, Planning, Resources, etc. to teach from like our mainstream counterparts.

Tony Attwood

Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.

I offer a, you want b. Argh!

0 comments

Posted on 5th December 2011 by admin in Uncategorized

 EXTRA DATE for shared mailing to all primary school (with free emails): 3 Jan 2012.

Would you believe it.  I pick a date for shared postal mailings to primary schools in January, offer free emails to go with it, and then find that some firms want to go out on another date – but still with the free emails.
But as always your command is my wish (or have I got that back to front), so here is an extra date for a shared mailing to ALL 24,000 primary schools, which comes complete with a free email promotion of your choice.
The date of despatch for the mailing to all 24000 primary schools is 3 January, 2012 and the final absolute last delivery date of materials is 16 December 2011.
To be clear, we are still also offering the shared postal mailing to 5000 largest primary schools on 10 January (delivery by 4 January – but it is best to get the leaflets to us by 22 December.)
Prices
All 5000 primary schools £388 (1 leaflet up to 15g)
All 24000 primary schools £1499 (1 leaflet up to 15g)
Please call to book in, or for any clarifications.   There’s full details of all our postal shared services on www.shared.org.uk and details of the free email lists that you can have with a shared mailing are on www.emails.gs
Tony
Hamilton House Mailings Ltd reg number 2444392 VAT 354907535GB.  Phone 01536 399 000.